Open it now or save it for another year? Even people who work with wine for a living can give different answers about the same bottle. At blind tastings in five cities, 87 of 140 wine professionals judged a 35-year-old Argentine Cabernet Sauvignon past its prime. The other 53 thought it was at its best or would improve with more time.
Wine scientist Roy Urvieta of the Catena Institute of Wine in Mendoza, Argentina, and an international team report the results November 20 in npj Science of Food. Wine professionals in Bordeaux, London, São Paulo, Chengdu and Davis, Calif., tasted 13 Argentine wines without knowing the vintages. They rated how much they liked each wine and estimated when it would taste its best. In general, they gave older reds less time.
Even the same taster could change their mind. The researchers slipped a second pour of a young Malbec into the lineup. On that second taste, 57 people gave the wine more time to reach its peak and 31 gave it less. The other 52 stuck with their first answer.
Every wine came from the same Argentine winery, which is affiliated with the institute that partly funded the study. Everyone tasted the wines in the same order, and the researchers would need to revisit the wines over time to see how well those forecasts held up.
The researchers argue that “the distribution of judgments is more informative than any single category per wine.” A recommendation to hold a bottle for five more years may be one of several answers you’d get around the same table.
The research
Cross-cultural assessment of wine aging potential and sensory profiles by wine professionals ↗
Roy Urvieta, Annegret Cantu, Gus Jian Zhu, Fernando Buscema, Laura Catena, Alexandre Pons and Hildegarde Heymann
npj Science of Food · Accepted
DOI: 10.1038/s41538-026-01229-0