Earlier scans had found smaller muscles near the spine in people with chronic back pain. Researchers expected to see a similar difference across the midsection. But when they compared abdominal CT scans from more than 5,000 patients with and without a low back pain diagnosis, overall muscle area was about the same in both groups.
Kathryn Marusich, a mechanical engineering researcher at Stanford University in California, and coauthors report the findings November 19 in PLOS Digital Health. They compared 2,622 patients diagnosed with low back pain with 2,577 patients matched for age, sex and body mass index.
Software measured muscle and fat in a single slice from each patient’s abdominal CT scan, at the level of the third lumbar vertebra. After accounting for body size, the groups had similar total muscle area. People with back pain had a slightly lower ratio of muscle to total abdominal fat, although the association was small.
“We were surprised that our low back pain group did not have less overall muscle than the controls. This finding doesn’t dismiss muscle as unimportant, but it does underscore the complexity of low back pain and how any differences in muscle size may be more localized,” Marusich said in a PLOS news release.
These measurements describe size, not strength, endurance or coordination. The study did not test whether strengthening exercises relieve pain.
The records came from one hospital, and the comparison patients were not necessarily healthy. Diagnosis codes did not reveal how severe or persistent the pain was. Because the analysis captured a snapshot rather than following changes over time, it cannot establish whether body composition contributed to pain or changed afterward.
Measuring individual muscles near the spine could reveal differences that get lost when researchers add up the muscle area across the whole midsection.
The research
Kathryn R. Marusich, Anthony A. Gatti, Louis Blankemeier, Robert D. Boutin, Matthew Smuck, Garry E. Gold, Scott L. Delp and Akshay S. Chaudhari
PLOS Digital Health · Published
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pdig.0001788